Site Meter Parent Extremis » Blog Archive » When your child’s life is at stake

When your child’s life is at stake

by Michael Davidsen

Should you only spank your child when his life is in danger?

I’ve talked to some authoritarian parents about this. The question is, what kinds of things can put your child’s life in danger? We all agree that cars and trucks in the street can do it, so we all keep our children out of the busy street. In high-crime neighborhoods, some parents keep their children off the street even when there are no cars, if you see what I mean.

Some conservative Christian parents insist, perhaps tongue-in-cheek, that they would never spank their child except when the child’s life is at stake. They quote verses such as Ezekiel 18:4, which says, “The person that sins will die.”

Does disobedience itself put your child’s life in danger? Is disobedience itself a “dangerous behavior”? In a dangerous world, it becomes more obvious. In a world of flash floods and wild predators, disobedience can be deadly.

Is it as obvious in our world?


3 Responses to “When your child’s life is at stake”

  1. Jean Lockwood Says:

    I decided to be brave, and answer your question.
    We do spank, but not often. We spank for direct disobedience (My husband or I have
    specifically said… and they disobey on
    purpose), life threatening things (running
    in the road, parking lot, etc; putting
    things other than a plug into an outlet,
    trying to carve wood without parental permission or supevision,etc.),
    repeat offences that they will not give up any other way (constantly whining, arguing with us as parents).
    The reason we don’t have to spank often is that we are consistant and our kids obey us and respect us. They feel free to talk to us, and we accept that they are each different from the others- and so we work with what works best with each child.
    We also allow them to explain themselves, so they know we are fair.
    I have seen some horrible examples of “spanking”, and believe that if you are in a moment of anger, you need to NOT spank. There is nothing wrong with calming down and then dealing with the problem. There is a lot wrong with letting yourself get out of control.
    That’s my $.02 worth.

  2. Michael Davidsen Says:

    I appreciate your courage. Sure, no parent intends to harm or spoil their child. But if we’re ruled by rules or emotions, instead of wisdom and knowledge of our child, discipline can have unplanned consequences.

  3. Jean Lockwood Says:

    I agree, that is why they are each disciplined according to what works best with them, not by the rule of “we always do this for that”.
    We let them know the consequences of their potential actions regularly- but we also praise positive actions and behavior.
    I am always telling my kids how proud I am of them, and that I am so blessed to have kids who behave well in public so I can take them with me when I go out.
    I think the positive reinforcement is a very important part of discipline, but so are having consequences that they can count on.

Leave a Reply


About Parent Extremis

Why are so many children unhealthy or apathetic or abused or illiterate or uncontrolled? That's why parents are desperate to try something new from the start. You're at the right place if the subject is home birth or homeschooling, attachment or separation, circumcision or vaccinations, natural remedies or television, gentle parenting or authoritative parenting, discipline or freedom.

Parent Extremis Author(s)
    » Stacy-Kravitz

Blogging Flair

Parenting & Family Channel Posts

  • Green Toys
    If you are a regular reader of my other blog (and you should be!) you will know I have been trying to live green and buy responsibly this Christmas season. PlanToys is one such company that I [...]
  • Little Cupcakes Company
    I love personalized items for my kids. I think when you can find something as original as your kids you should get it, because that is not easy to find. Enter Little Cupcakes Company, a unique [...]
  • 12 Days of Christmas ~ Give Away ~ Day Four ~ Mom is Teaching
                              Day Four is here!  AND A GIFT FOR [...]
  • Time to Decorate!
    We haven't picked out our tree yet - that's a fun job for this weekend, I think. What to put on it...hmmm. My mother thinks it's a basic human right for children to have a Christmas tree, so she [...]
  • And, the winner is....
                                    of Day [...]
  • Safest Cars For Families
    A report by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety out today lists these vehicles as the ones that do the best job protecting in front, side and rear crashes. The best minvans and trucks [...]
  • Easier to Enter and Win
                                 So, let's make this a little [...]
  • Homeschooling Article
    Hey, high-lighting the homeschoolers again and I read this article but couldn't have written about it like this....so I'm going to just send you on over to her place with a link.....mmmkay? [...]
  • 12 Days of Christmas ~ Give Away ~ Day Three ~ Mom is Teaching
                             Where is everyone....?  Come on out and get in the [...]
  • Get The Kissing Disease for Christmas!
    We talk about sex around here. A lot. Mostly because I'm as bad as the kids and have the mind of a 16 year old boy, but whatever. Some folks think I'm nuts for the way we talk and joke and laugh [...]

Hot Off The Press