Site Meter Parent Extremis » Blog Archive » Hospital births no more dangerous than home birth, says British Medical Journal

Hospital births no more dangerous than home birth, says British Medical Journal

by

Okay, that’s not how the British Medical Journal announced it, but I couldn’t resist. Specifically, the study showed that when parents plan to give birth at home (as we did), even if they have to go to the hospital later (as we did), they are subject to fewer interventions, such as epidurals, episiotomies and caesarian sections.

Midwives transfered their clients to the hospital about 12% of the time, but only considered it urgent in 3.4% of the cases. Even after the transfer, intervention rates were much lower for the women who had planned a home birth than those who had planned a hospital birth: more than ten times lower for some procedures. “Compared with the relatively low risk hospital group, intended home births were associated with lower rates of electronic fetal monitoring (9.6% versus 84.3%), episiotomy (2.1% versus 33.0%), caesarean section (3.7% versus 19.0%), and vacuum extraction (0.6% versus 5.5%).”

But that’s not the part I thought was most interesting. The study shows, perhaps without meaning to, that with all the interventions and medical additions that happen in a hospital delivery room, childbirth is not safer there than it is at home. But maybe not any less safe. According to the study. Just less enjoyable.

The study concludes, “Planned home birth for low risk women in North America using certified professional midwives was associated with lower rates of medical intervention but similar intrapartum and neonatal mortality to that of low risk hospital births in the United States.”

Babylune in Ontario says that midwives there can’t meet the demand. What would the demand be in the US if parents here knew more about the home birth option?


5 Responses to “Hospital births no more dangerous than home birth, says British Medical Journal”

  1. Kate Says:

    I think you are providing a service by talking about the issue of midwife-attended home birth! Many doctors are ignorant of the safety aspects and actively discourage their patients from learning more.

    With super bugs and other antibiotic-resistant infections in the hospitals, I am avoiding hospitals even more.

  2. Michael Davidsen Says:

    As hard as our labor was, dealing with the hospital was even worse.

  3. faerylandmom Says:

    Amen. None of my kiddos were born in a hospital, and I’m so happy I educated myself before just accepting the “status quo” U.S. hospital birth. :) Thank you for posting this.

  4. Summer Says:

    As a labor doula I had to study about the common hospital interventions, even more so because while I was training I was pregnant with my second child. A typical hospital birth, complete with all the common interventions that doctors and nurses often guilt mothers into getting or out right lie and say they need, is often more dangerous than a home birth. Our bodies know what to do just fine. Its when we try to fool nature and control the natural process that complications start to arrise. As evidenced by the US’s abizmal 30%(and growing) c-section rate.

    There was a US study in 1996 that concluded the same thing. http://gentlebirth.org/ronnie/homesafe.html

  5. Free Medical Advice Says:

    While we are discussing Parent Extremis » Blog Archive » Hospital births no more dangerous than home birth, says British Medical Journal, The career advice service provided by medical schools and deaneries has improved greatly, but specialty programmes need to identify ways of supporting those trainees who need time and experience in the postgraduate setting to make a firm commitment that will match their eventual career destination.

Leave a Reply


About Parent Extremis

Why are so many children unhealthy or apathetic or abused or illiterate or uncontrolled? That's why parents are desperate to try something new from the start. You're at the right place if the subject is home birth or homeschooling, attachment or separation, circumcision or vaccinations, natural remedies or television, gentle parenting or authoritative parenting, discipline or freedom.

Parent Extremis Author(s)

Blogging Flair

Parenting & Family Channel Posts

  • Monsanto Roundup
    With nine million litres of Roundup sold each year all over the world, the American agrochemical group Monsanto holds a world record. For the first time, a study led by Gilles-Eric Séralini [...]
  • What a proud parent does?
    So, there’s the looming talk of “candy at school” but thus far my son doesn’t seem to be any the wiser about how the whole “no more candy” came to be.  I’m trying to be objective, [...]
  • To prove I’m not the perfect parent
    My children are having a hard time with the fact that their mommy has been gone quite a bit lately.  And, I’m home now with no chance of traveling for quite some time and hopefully, if I do [...]
  • Cooking with Kids
    Bo is a great helper. I love to make cookies with Peanut. It's our fun mother/daughter activity. For a while, every time she took a nap, she'd ask if we could make chocolate chips when she [...]
  • Sleep: A Chance to Dream and For Mom to Get a Break
    I love sleep. It is in my top five of favorite things to do. Having a baby kind of ruins this though! The Little Guy is slowly getting better at sleeping. Many mornings, he's out cold at [...]
  • So, I really hate to complain but candy? Really?
    Here’s the deal.  You all know that my son is a talker and that thus far his teacher has been more than a little bit receptive to the fact that he NEVER.SHUTS.UP.  She seems to be [...]
  • Ok, so let’s talking Parenting…mmmkay?
    Ok, so yea, I get it, I’m a parent but not everyone wants to hear me tell parenting stories.  So, I figure, I’ll give you one little parenting story and then guide you in the direction of [...]
  • Do You Pull Up?
    The other day, I was working. I really was. I was doing some research, and I happened upon an article about Tori Spelling. She talked about her son, Liam's, potty training process. Here's a [...]
  • Electroshocking Toddlers?
    American psychiatry still regards electroconvulsive therapy as a respected treatment, even for kids. Although ECT for young children is nowhere near as common as for adults, most U.S. states [...]
  • Babies having babies.
    Mama always said that she was a 'baby that had a baby' when she got pregnant with me a mere WEEK after her wedding to Papa. She and I still look like sisters (I'm the YOUNGER one, dammit!), and we [...]

Hot Off The Press